How Much Should you Spend on an Engagement Ring?


Engagement rings hold a special place in the hearts of many; they symbolize love, commitment, and the start of a new chapter in a couple’s life. However, with so many options available in the market today, deciding how much you should spend on this significant piece of jewellery can take time and effort. 

Tradition often dictates spending an equivalent of two or three months’ salary, but is that still the right move for today’s couples?

In this article, we’ll delve into the different factors you should consider when setting your engagement ring budget without compromising the value and meaning of this timeless symbol of love. From determining your financial situation to understanding the various ring features that impact the overall cost, we’ll provide you with the guidance needed to make an informed decision.

Setting a budget: Factors to consider before purchasing an engagement ring  

                Engagement Ring in yellow god custom made in Toronto.

When setting a budget for an engagement ring, there are several factors to consider before making your final decision. 

First and foremost, you want to ensure that you can comfortably afford the ring without putting yourself in financial strain. It’s essential to be realistic and prioritize your current financial situation and future financial goals

Another factor to consider is your partner’s expectations and desires. Communication is key – openly discuss with your partner about their preferences and ring styles they admire. This will help you choose the perfect ring and ensure it meets their expectations.

Remember that it’s not the ring’s price that truly matters but the love and commitment it symbolizes. So, while finding the perfect ring is important, avoid getting caught up in following societal norms or feeling pressured to spend beyond your means. Your love story is unique, and so should your engagement ring purchase.

Determining your partner’s preferences: Style, metal, and stone options

When determining your partner’s preferences for an engagement ring, you’ll want to pay close attention to their style, favourite metals, and ideal stone options. 

Start by observing your partner’s everyday jewellery choices

Are they drawn to classic or trendy pieces? 

Is there a particular metal colour that they favour – yellow, white, or rose gold? 

Next, consider the type of gemstones they usually prefer. A traditional diamond is always a safe choice, but perhaps they’d rather have a more unique option, like a sapphire or emerald?

Lastly, engage in casual conversations about their dream engagement ring. Listen to any hints they may give about their desired style, diamond shape, and overall design. By considering these factors, you’ll be well on your way to finding a ring that perfectly represents your partner and your unique love story.

The 4 Cs: Understanding cut, carat, clarity, and colour

When choosing the perfect engagement ring, understanding the 4 Cs of diamond quality is essential. These four characteristics – cut, carat, clarity, and colour – will help you determine your budget’s best value and beauty.

Cut refers to how a diamond is shaped and how well it reflects light. A well-cut diamond will have incredible brilliance and sparkle. In contrast, a poorly-cut diamond will appear dull, even if it is a 4 carat ring.

Carat is the unit of measurement for a diamond’s weight, with one carat equaling 200 milligrams. Larger carats typically mean a more expensive diamond. Still, the other three Cs play a significant role in determining the value.

Clarity measures the presence of imperfections, also known as inclusions, within a diamond. Fewer and less noticeable inclusions lead to higher clarity grades and more valuable diamonds.

Colour evaluates a diamond’s hue, ranging from colourless (the most desirable) to slightly yellow or brown. Diamonds with less colour are rarer and more valuable. Diamonds with a brown tinge tend to be less expensive and less desirable.

Each of these factors will impact your engagement ring’s overall look and cost. Therefore, it’s important to consider your partner’s preferences, budget, and the 4 Cs when deciding.

Balancing the budget and quality: Tips for getting the best value for your money

Balancing your budget with quality can feel daunting when purchasing an engagement ring. But fear not, as we have some tips to help you make the best decision while keeping your wallet in mind.

Establish a clear budget and stick to it. There’s no need to start your life together in debt over an engagement ring. Instead, consider alternative diamond shapes; a less traditional cut can still offer sparkle and elegance while costing less than a round-cut diamond. 

Please don’t get caught up in the quest for the perfect diamond; prioritize your partner’s preferences and choose a ring that reflects their personality and style

Opt for a setting made of a more affordable metal, such as white gold, to help cut costs while maintaining a luxurious appearance. 

Always shop around to ensure you get the best value for your money. Comparing different jewellers and evaluating options based on quality, price, and reputation will lead you to the perfect engagement ring while respecting your budget. 

One critical factor that is often overlooked is finding a jeweller you can trust that has your interests in mind before their own. Make sure to ask lots of questions. Be aware of their answers and how they align with your own values. 

Considering alternative options: Lab-grown diamonds, gemstones, and vintage rings

If traditional engagement rings seem too expensive, some fantastic alternatives should be considered. 

Lab-grown diamonds, for example, can be significantly more affordable than their natural counterparts while retaining the same beauty, sparkle and chemical composition. In addition, these ethical stones are also conflict-free and environmentally friendly, making them a responsible choice for the conscious consumer.

Another stunning idea is to choose a gemstone as the central piece. Sapphires, rubies, and emeralds are all timeless classics that offer a unique and colourful twist on tradition.

Vintage rings can be a charming and cost-effective choice for those seeking something with a little history. Browsing antique shops or online vintage retailers might just lead to the perfect, one-of-a-kind piece that already holds a unique story.

Online vs. in-store shopping: Pros and cons of both options

In the digital age, shopping for the perfect engagement ring has never been easier. But is purchasing online the right move for you, or should you stick to the traditional in-store experience? 

Online shopping offers convenience, as you can browse countless options from the comfort of your own home. It also provides access to a larger variety of options and, often, better prices due to reduced overhead expenses. However, online shopping comes with risks, such as potential issues with the ring’s quality and aftercare and support. 

Many large online retailers currently do not have brick-and-mortar locations to visit for sizing or repairs. Keep in mind rings are usually worn daily and get knocked around quite a bit. It’s good to have a reputable jeweller you can count on to assist in these situations. As well, in-store shopping allows you to physically hold and see the ring in person, making it easier to judge the quality and fit. Diamonds and jewellery look very different at times on a screen. You also have knowledgeable staff and the ability to create custom pieces. 

Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and priorities. Consider the pros and cons of both options to make an informed decision for your engagement ring purchase.

Insurance and warranties: Protecting your investment

One crucial aspect to consider when purchasing an engagement ring is protecting your investment with insurance. Although the thought of something happening to your precious piece may be disheartening, it’s essential to be prepared for the unexpected.

Insuring your engagement ring guarantees you’re financially covered in theft, loss, or damage. To ensure adequate protection, it is crucial to have an insurance policy tailored for jewellery. This can either be a standalone policy or an extension of your renter’s or homeowner’s insurance. We recommend discussing this with an experienced insurance professional.

Safeguard your token of love by insuring your engagement ring – a small price for peace of mind.

In summary, there really is no right or wrong answer in regard to how much to spend on an engagement ring. Think of your partner. Focus on what she would like most. Make sure to work with someone you trust. Do your research and make sure you feel comfortable with the jeweller you choose to work with. 


27 Queen St E #1004
Toronto, ON M5C 2M6

Call or Text Message:

(416) 861-8204

Hours of Operation:

Monday – Thursday – 9:00am – 5:30pm EST
Friday – 9:00am – 4:00pm EST
Saturday – By Appointment Only 

Evening and Saturday Consultations are Available by Appointment

Say Hello!

We are here to help. Ask a question or request an appointment below.

oval rose gold diamond ring

Available By Appointment Only.

Monday – Thursday 9:00am – 5:30pm EST
Friday – 9:00am – 4:00pm EST

Click here for up-to-date hours

Evening and Saturday Consultations are Available

Download our idea book.

Enter your information below